There's a Big Difference Between “My Teen Is Fine” and “I Think My Teen Is Fine”

The weekend we launched the I’m Paying Attention Challenge: Road to 100,000, more than 1,500 parents took the Teen Signal Check.

A lot of them wrote to me afterward. One question kept coming up.

“My son’s away at school. He texts maybe once a week. How am I supposed to answer questions about his sleep?”

Fair question. I didn’t have a good answer.

The first versions of the Teen Signal Check made you pick. Is he sleeping more or less? Has she pulled away from friends? You had to choose something, so people chose something.

I’d bet a lot of them chose the hopeful answer. I would have.

So in version 3 we added a fourth colour. Green, yellow, red, and now white. White means “I don’t know.”

At first I thought it was a small fix. It turned out to be the most honest part of the whole check.

Think about who answers “I don’t know.”

The parent whose kid is in residence three provinces away.

The parent who sees their teen every other weekend.

The grandparent, the coach, the aunt who knows something’s off but only sees them at Sunday dinner.

Giving your kid space and not wanting to provoke an argument creates a gap in information. I know, because this was my default setting with Maddie after her mom and me separated.

None of these people are doing anything wrong. They just have less to go on. And until now, the check made them guess.

Here’s what changed my thinking.

A green result with four or five “I don’t knows” in it is a different result. It’s green with the lights off.

That parent isn’t in the clear. They’re missing information. Those are two different places to be, and they call for different next steps.

Green says keep paying attention. Green with a lot of white says go find out.

“Go find out” makes some parents nervous. They picture a sit-down. Twenty questions at the kitchen table. A kid looking for the exit.

You can skip all that.

Look at the questions where you answered “I don’t know.” Pick one. Just one.

If it’s sleep, you might notice what time the light goes off when they’re home. If it’s friends, you might ask about one friend by name and see what comes back. If they’re away, you might call on a weeknight for no reason.

Sometimes the answer comes from someone else who sees them more. A sibling. A coach. The other parent.

You’re filling in the picture slowly. Nobody needs to feel investigated.

Admitting you don’t know something about your own kid is uncomfortable. Most of us would rather guess and feel fine.

I’m a guy who once drove forty minutes the wrong way rather than ask for directions. I understand the appeal of guessing.

But “I don’t know” is information. It tells you exactly where to look.

If you took the Teen Signal Check before we added white, take it again. Answer honestly this time. Let the blanks be blank.

Take the Teen Signal Check

It’s free, there’s no email required, and it takes about three minutes.

“I don’t know” is where paying attention starts.

If you or your teen are struggling right now, call or text 988 in Canada or the US. In Canada, teens can also reach Kids Help Phone at 1-800-668-6868 or text 686868.

Previous
Previous

I Can Hear You Waiting for Me to Be Done Grieving

Next
Next

Why the Holidays Hit Teens Harder Than They Let On, And a Daily Ritual That Can Hold Them Together